Despite the wealth and power Jeffrey Epstein amassed, his voice had a slight but indelible Brooklyn, working class inflection. As I augered into Epstein’s genetic pool, I had to contend with a jigsaw puzzle whose various pieces often didn’t interconnect. I’ve found that cobbling together a coherent genealogy of Epstein has a degree of difficulty that is like cobbling together a coherent understanding of his life.
Epstein’s first set of paternal great-grandparents, Samuel Tesher and Esther Goldfarb, were Ashkenazi Jews born in Russia. According to the 1900 Census, Samuel was born in 1850 and Esther was born in 1858. The 1800s were not an auspicious era to be Jewish and living in Eastern Europe or Russia, because it was a hotbed of antisemitism: Jews were subjected to pogroms and other unsavory treatment.
Samuel Tesher immigrated from Russia to America in 1884. His wife Esther and their two oldest children, Max and Bessie, immigrated to America in 1891. At the time, Bessie, who would become Jeffrey Epstein’s maternal grandmother, was 4 years old. Samuel listed his occupation as a “tailor.” Samuel and Esther would have four additional children: George, Louis, Sarah, and Mammie, who were born in New York City.
The next set of Epstein’s paternal great-grandparents, Morris Epstein and Sarah Kaplan, were Ashkenazi Jews native to Poland. Morris was born in 1862, and Sarah was born in 1865. An eastern swath of Poland had been subjugated by the Russian Empire earlier in the century, and it was a hotbed of antisemitism, too.
Morris Epstein and Sarah Kaplan were married in circa 1881, and the couple became a procreating dynamo, bearing a brood of at least 9 sons and 6 daughters. Morris, Sarah, and their children fled Poland in 1899 and landed in New York City.
The couple’s oldest progeny, Julius, was Jeffrey Epstein’s paternal grandfather. His World War II “Registration Card” for the draft states that he was born on September 15, 1882, in Białystok, Poland, even though the 1920 Census states he was born in Russia. The 1920 Census also states he was naturalized in 1907.
Julius Epstein and Bessie Tesher were married in January of 1916.
Julius’s World War I Draft Registration Card, 1917–1918, states that he and Bessie lived at 769 Willoughby Avenue in the Bedford-Stuyvesant neighborhood of Brooklyn, which, at the time, was a vibrant working- and middle-class Jewish community. Under “Present Occupation” was written “truckman,” which meant Julius was a truck driver.
Though Julius dropped out of school in the 8th grade, he proved to be industrious. The 1920 Census lists Julius as the “proprietor” of a Brooklyn-based “house wrecking” company, and the 1930 Census lists his occupation as a “house wrecker.” The coffers of Julius’s demolition company were enhanced by the Works Progress Administration, a New Deal initiative to employ largely unemployed Americans to build public infrastructures like roads, schools, and parks. The 1940 Census lists Julius as a “contractor” who was in the business of “house wrecking.”
Oddly, Julius registered for the WWII draft when he was 60 years old. Apparently, Julius had relinquished his demolition company, because he listed Nostrand Estates as his employer. Nostrand Estates owned various properties in Brooklyn that were used for manufacturing. He rented a three-bedroom apartment in the Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn.
The oldest son of Julius and Bessie, Seymour, was born on December 4, 1916, and he would ultimately sire Jeffrey. The couple had a second son, Arnold Harold Epstein, in 1923. After the birth of her sons, Bessie suffered a “nervous breakdown” and underwent shock therapy.
Seymour dropped out of high school and worked for his father's demolition company. In the 1940 Census, Seymour lists “clerk” as his occupation and “House Wrecking” as his industry. Seymour’s 1940 World War II Draft Card states his age as 23 years old and his address as 510 Crown Street, in the Crown Heights neighborhood of Brooklyn.
Seymour’s World War II Enlistment Records show that he enlisted in the Navy in 1941 when he was 25 years old. Moreover, Seymour’s “Voter Registers” from October 11, 1945, state he is on “Terminal Leave” from the Navy, which is the final authorized absence of a sailor when he or she uses up their accumulated, unused leave (time off duty) right before they are discharged or retire from active duty.
However, the World War II Hospital Admission Card for a Seymour Epstein maintains that his “Admission Date” to the Navy was January of 1944, and his “Discharge Date” from the Navy was January 1944. The Hospital Admission Card states that he was unfit for service, because of hallux valgus, which sounds like a rare, terminal disease. But, in actuality, hallux valgus is a minor foot deformity in which the big toe curves toward the second toe, causing a bony bump near the big toe that can cause pain, swelling, and difficulty wearing standard shoes.
The contradiction is inexplicable.
Julius died in 1944. He was 62 years old and interred at Wellwood Cemetery in West Babylon, New York.
Upon Seymour’s return to civilian life, he held various jobs that included construction work, selling cutlery at Macy's, and working as a subway conductor. The 1950 Census lists his vocation as a clothing salesman.
In 1952, as Seymour was bouncing from job to job, he married Pauline “Paula” Stolofsky. Paula, a native of New York, was born in 1918. Paula’s father, Max Stolofsky, born in 1893, was a native of Lithuania. According to the 1910 Census, Max immigrated to the United States in 1909 and worked as a tailor for Mercy Coats. The 1930 Census states Paula’s mother, Sora-Leia “Lena” Berlin, was a native of Poland and born circa 1895. The 1920 Census notes that she arrived in the United States in 1914. She married Max Stolofsky in 1916. Max and Lena had four daughters: Paula, Frances, Ruth, and Miriam.
After Seymour and Paula were married, they moved to Coney Island, where Paula’s parents were living. At the time, Coney Island was a haven for middle-class Jewish families. Seymour ultimately found vocational stability in 1956, working for the New York City Parks Department as a gardener, earning less than $8,000 a year. Paula was initially a homemaker who then became a middle school aide.
Seymour and Paula would have two sons: Jeffrey Edward, born on January 20, 1953, and Mark Lawrence, born on July 14, 1954.
The Public Records Index notes that Seymour and Paula relocated to West Palm Beach in 1987. In the 1980s, their eldest son, Jeffrey, was on the escalator to upward mobility, but he didn’t purchase his Palm Beach mansion at 358 El Brillo Way for $2.5 million until 1990.
Thus far, Jeffrey Epstein’s background doesn’t seem remarkable. Granted, the dates and the countries of origin for some of his forebears are not entirely in sync, but record keeping at the turn of the 20th century was extremely archaic. However, Seymour’s obituary on the site ancestors.family.search is initially perplexing. The obituary correctly notes that Seymour was born on December 4, 1991, and he worked for the New York City Department of Parks and Recreation as a groundskeeper and gardener. It also states that he entered the military in 1941, which coincides with his World War II Enlistment Records. However, the obituary mentions that he died in an accident on December 14, 1991, in Cleveland, Ohio, while working for the Administration of Environmental Quality and Housing Programs. The sites Geni and Wikitree also maintain that Seymour died in Cleveland, Ohio, in 1991.
The Administration of Environmental Quality and Housing Programs oversees the following:
Given Seymour’s employment history, lack of vivacity, and his move to Florida after his retirement, he fits into the mold of a retiree who receives a full pension and fades away from the nine-to-five. He definitely doesn’t fit into the mold of a sexagenarian who retires with a New York City pension and then becomes a federal employee of the Administration of Environmental Quality and Housing Programs.
Seymour’s “Death Record” reveals that he was in a fatal crash in Cleveland on December 14, 1991, and pronounced dead at 5:25 AM. Seymour was 75 years old.
Seymour definitely seems to be a retiree who would be difficult to dislodge from the sunny and balmy climes of Florida for frosty Cleveland in December.
Seymour’s “Death Record” states that he wasn’t referred to a coroner, and his death was certified by a physician. Cleveland is in Cuyahoga County, so I phoned the Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner's Office. I was provided with two extremely surprising facts. First, I was told that the case of an automobile accident fatality is almost invariably referred to a coroner instead of a physician. Second, there is no record of a Seymour Epstein dying on December 14, 1991, in Cleveland. But his death was recorded at the Cleveland Clinic, which is a nonprofit academic medical center based in Cleveland that offers preeminent and cutting-edge health care for myriad conditions and maladies.
After I talked to the Cuyahoga County Medical Examiner's Office, I typed “Seymour” into the Justice Department’s “Epstein Library” search engine and gleaned 305 “results,” many of which were redundancies.
An email exchange between Jeffrey Epstein and Mark Epstein, his brother, on June 25, 2016, provides Seymour’s rationale for visiting Cleveland in December. Jeffrey writes the following in his characteristically butchered grammar: “i had some angio edema. my lip swelled up from nowhere. they asked if paula or seymour ever had the same / I have no recolalection ? you” And Mark responds with an email: “When Seymour was in Cleveland at the end he had some edema but that was from the operations and his not getting over them well. He died, but I doubt that is a connection to your current situation.”
(Angioedema is caused by a fluid buildup in deep skin tissues, and it produces a sudden swelling under the skin that often affects the eyes, lips, hands, feet, or throat. If angioedema becomes an impediment to breathing, it requires emergency care.)
So, apparently, Seymour was being treated for angioedema at the Cleveland Clinic.
Seymour was interred at the Star of David Cemetery in Palm Beach County.
Paula died in 2004, and she was interred at the Star of David Cemetery in Palm Beach County.
Jeffrey Epstein would be interred at the Star of David Cemetery next to his parents in 2019.
I delved into Jeffrey Epstein's genealogy to see if there was a salient tell with regards to his extreme deviance. But I seemingly found only normality, which makes his story all the more horrifying.
