Republican Dennis Hastert, former Speaker of the House from 1999 to 2007, died this week.[1] During those years, he was constitutionally the third most powerful man in the country, and he established a reputation in the House as being a strong-arm specialist.[2] Hastert, however, had concealed pedophilic predations for decades throughout his meteoric political ascent.[3] As the revelations about Hastert became increasingly sordid, and the story incited a media feeding frenzy, a federal judge, siding with federal prosecutors, ruled that discovery in the case would not be made public.[4] Then, suddenly, the news about Hastert’s predatory behavior quickly evaporated.
Hastert’s illicit sex with minors stunned a nation. But in a 2006 investigation, the House Ethics Committee ruled that Hastert and other Republicans were “willfully ignorant” for months in their response to recurring warnings that U.S. Representative Mark Foley was preying on teenage, congressional male pages.[5] In 2009, an F.B.I. whistleblower, Sibel Edmonds, testified during a deposition that the F.B.I. was cognizant of Hastert visiting a Chicago townhouse for “certain not very morally accepted activities” during his speakership.[6] If the whistleblower’s revelations are true, then F.B.I. personnel were aware of Hastert’s shadow life, but, nonetheless, he was publicly unscathed by it during his years as Speaker of the House.
In 2016, Dennis Hastert pleaded guilty to illegally structuring bank withdrawals. He withdrew $952,000 in cash from various bank accounts in increments under $10,000 to avoid federal reporting requirements. The money was used to buy the silence of an individual whom he had sexually abused decades earlier when he was employed as a high school teacher and wrestling coach. Hastert had allegedly struck a deal in 2010 to pay his former victim $3.5 million in compensation to conceal Hastert’s “prior misconduct” against him.[7]
He was sentenced to 15 months in federal prison by U.S. District Judge Thomas M. Durkin for illegally structuring bank withdrawals, but prosecutors were aware that Hastert had molested an unspecified number of underage boys.
Since blackmail is illegal, it seems only logical that Hastert’s blackmailer would feel the wrath of the F.B.I. instead of the highly esteemed former Speaker of the House. So, the million-dollar question is why the F.B.I. opted to take down Hastert instead of his blackmailer.
I’ve used the analogy of “the yacht” when describing individuals who are compromised. Once they’re blackmailed, it’s like they’re on a yacht: It’s a beautiful yacht, and it’s a beautiful day. The yacht’s occupants can have whatever tickles their fancy when they’re on the yacht. But if they make the ill-fated decision to depart the yacht, the people on the yacht will ensure that they drown.
If Hastert was on the figurative yacht, we will never know his rationale for exiting it. Several news outlets have reported that Hastert made millions of dollars as a lobbyist after retiring from the House.[8] Perchance did he become too greedy and feel he was above giving his puppeteers a cut? Maybe he stepped on a few toes en route to amassing millions of dollars?
I’ve found that Americans have a collective naiveté about their politicians’ sexcapades, believing that they are the dalliances and moral failings of a select few. My fellow Americans have great difficulty accepting that many of our politicians are endowed with a potent psychological alchemy of power, arrogance, and lust that fluently translates into extramarital affairs, aberrant behavior, and even illicit deeds.
Political blackmail is rarely made public, and if it becomes public, then it generally occurs years after the fact. J. Edgar Hoover is a prime example: He was a blackmail artist for decades, and his blackmailing only emerged years after his death.[9] Blackmail marks, especially politicians, have zero incentive to turn to the authorities if the blackmailer has pictures of their illicit, highly aberrant, or extramarital sexual conduct. Those pictures, released to the public, would doom their careers, probably destroy their families, and reduce their lives to public ignominy.
Sexual, political blackmail is a time-honored tradition in America. The husband of Alexander Hamilton’s 23-year-old mistress financially extorted Hamilton to ensure that his affair remained surreptitious.[10] After a muckraking journalist exposed Hamilton’s affair, the married Hamilton undoubtedly suffered a blemish on his reputation.[11] Hamilton and Jefferson were antagonists, and the muckraker who outed Hamilton’s extramarital affair felt that Jefferson owed him a political appointment when Jefferson became president.[12] But Jefferson declined, and the muckraker disseminated news about Jefferson’s affair with one of his slaves.[13]
Although a procession of hagiographies has elevated America’s Founding Fathers to saint-like status, they nonetheless had their sexual foibles that made them susceptible to blackmail. As I’ve researched and written about sexual, political blackmail in America, I’ve come to believe that if love is, in fact, blind, then lust is deaf, dumb, and quadriplegic. Metaphorically speaking, of course, many of our politicians are in need of motorized wheelchairs.
I’ve wondered if our current Speaker of the House, Mike Johnson, is compromised or if he is merely a President Donald Trump sycophant. Johnson chose to shut down Congress, so members of the House could not vote on a bill that would have mandated an investigation into Jeffrey Epstein’s pedophile network. Obviously, Johnson was under tremendous pressure to cover up the Epstein network’s child abuse.
Speaker Johnson and his 17-year-old son have a rather strange, cringe-worthy routine: They have Covenant Eyes software on their phones, which enables them to monitor each other’s consumption of pornography.[14] Given the cyber-spying abilities of our intelligence agencies, if Johnson has an affinity for macabre pornography or child abuse material, I believe it would be reasonable to surmise that he may be compromised.
[1] Carl Hulse, “Once-Calming Leader and a Stunning Turn,” New York Times, May 30, 2015, Late Edition, p. A11.
[2] Ibid.
[3] Julie Phillips Bosman, “Woman Says Her Brother Was Victim of Hastert: Sex Abuse Hidden for Years, She Adds,” New York Times, June 6, 2015, Late Edition, p. A10.
[4] Philip Giraldi, “Did Foreign Governments Blackmail Denny Hastert?” The American Conservative, October 20, 2015, https://www.theamericanconservative.com/articles/how-a-plea-deal-for-hastert-may-hide-the-truth. Accessed September 4, 2019.
[5] Jeff Zeleny, “Report Finds Negligence in Foley Case: Ethics Inquiry Faults Republicans, but Cites No Rule Violations,” New York Times, December 9, 2006, Late Edition, p. A14.
[6] Philip Giraldi, “Did Foreign Governments Blackmail Denny Hastert?”
[7] Tarini Parti, “How Dennis Hastert Made His Millions,” Politico, May 25, 2015.
[8] Jonathan Weisman, “After Speakership, Hastert Amassed His Millions Lobbying Former Colleagues,” New York Times, May 31, 2015, A14.
[9] Walter Goodman, “Revelations about J. Edgar Hoover,” New York Times, February 9, 1993, Late Edition, p. C16.
[10] Mark Silk, “Before the Scandal Broke,” Smithsonian, November 2016, p. 32.
[11] Ibid.
[12] Ibid.
[13] Ibid.
[14] Adam Gabbatt, “Mike Johnson Says in Resurfaced Video He Uses App that Helps People ‘quit porn,’” Guardian, November 6, 2023. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/nov/06/speaker-mike-johnson-covenant-eyes-app-quitting-porn
